Some handstand shapes are easier than others because of three angles: your shoulders, your spine and your hips. Most people have slightly tight shoulders, so the easiest shapes let one or both legs hang over the top as a counterbalance. A straight handstand comes next, and a tuck is the hardest of the three, because it needs the most open shoulders.
The three angles
Every handstand shape is some combination of three angles. That is all that is ever going on.
The shoulder angle is closed, straight or open. Most people are a little tight and their shoulders don't fully open; some can get straight without much work; a few, who are hypermobile or have worked on it a lot, can take their arms even further back.
The spine is straight or in a back bend. Occasionally it rounds into a tuck, but that is unusual in a handstand: typically people are either straight or want to be in a back arch.
The hip is closed, straight or opened back. Think in terms of these three things and any shape starts to make sense.
Centre of gravity decides the rest
To balance, your centre of gravity must be over your hands. If one part of your body is one way, another part must counterbalance it by going the opposite way. Your body will tuck into a ball naturally, but it can't open out into a back arch with the same ease, so the shoulder angle and the back bend are the major limits on the shapes you can make.
Easiest: legs over the top
Because most people have tight shoulders in a closed position, they need their legs to hang over the top of their head to counteract that shoulder angle. That is why you so often see yoga practitioners in a scorpion-like shape with a foot hanging over the top: it lets them have a bit of a back arch while their tight shoulders stay closed, and it feels more comfortable. It is the same reason you see strong gym athletes with their legs dangling over the top and their chest a little forward.
So the easiest shape to master is one foot over the top, both feet over the top, or some combination. There is nothing wrong with it. A foot hanging over the top can look even prettier, and it is a great shape.
Next: straight
The next most difficult shape is a straight handstand. A straight handstand is always limited by the shoulder angle, never the spine. In most cases everybody's spine can go straight and everybody's legs can go straight; the shoulders are what decide it.
Ben's own experience is reassuring. Just the process of practising handstands stretched his shoulder mobility into position, even without actively stretching. It will partly happen on its own if you drill away at it, although you may want to do some extra stretching to get there.
Hardest: tuck
The third most difficult shape is the tuck. When your leg weight comes to the front of your body, your bum has to stick out behind to counterbalance it, and for your bum to stick out there has to be an arch. That arch needs even more open shoulders.
So for people with tight shoulders, whose arms won't go there, the tuck just won't happen. It is nothing to do with willpower, effort, brute force or magic. It is simply centre of gravity, and the positions you can get your bodyweight into.
Why strong people struggle with the tuck
Very often weightlifters, powerlifters, bodybuilders and climbers, people with a lot of muscle and tight shoulders, can't get to a tuck, because their shoulders won't go back to counteract it. It is not that they aren't trying, it is not that they aren't strong, and it is not that they can't balance. It is a simple centre of gravity issue, and shoulder stretching is the way through it.
Shapes in between
There are plenty of shapes in between. Splitting your legs into a straddle or a split lowers your centre of gravity, which makes your balance easier to control: a split-leg handstand is actually easier than a regular straight handstand with your feet together at the top. Once you are comfortable, you can move between shapes, from a tuck, opening your knees out into a diamond and then a straddle, and closing back again.
What it means for a beginner
If you are starting out with slightly tight shoulders, let a foot or both feet hang over the top, and let that counterbalance your shoulders. That is your best bet. Work towards a straight handstand from there and then, if you have the mobility, work towards the tuck.
Practising your shapes
Whatever shape you choose, keep your legs straight and your toes pointed: tension in your legs helps you control the balance. Use the wall for confidence, or ask a friend to support your hips. Take a photo of yourself to see which angle is limiting you. And be patient: shoulders open with time and practice, and every shape you learn along the way is worth having.